How to Find the Right Therapist for You | Stickney Counseling

Getting Started

How to Find the Right Therapist for You

Finding a therapist can feel overwhelming. Here is what to actually look for — and the questions worth asking before you commit.

K
Kimberleigh Stickney, LMHC
••4 min read
How to Find the Right Therapist for You

Deciding to try therapy is a meaningful step. Finding the right therapist, though — that part can feel like a part-time job.

You search a directory, read a few bios that all sound the same, maybe send a few emails, wait for responses, and then try to figure out from a 15-minute phone call whether this person is someone you can trust with the things you've never said out loud.

It's a lot. And because the stakes feel high, a lot of people give up before they find someone who's actually a good fit.

Here's what I'd want you to know going in.

Credentials Matter — But They're Not the Whole Picture

A licensed therapist has completed graduate-level training, supervised clinical hours, and passed licensing exams. In the U.S., common credentials include:

  • LMHC (Licensed Mental Health Counselor) — Florida's primary counseling license
  • LCSW (Licensed Clinical Social Worker)
  • LPC (Licensed Professional Counselor) — used in North Carolina and many other states
  • PhD or PsyD — doctoral-level psychologists

All of these indicate a qualified clinician. What matters beyond credentials is whether their training, specialties, and approach match what you're dealing with.

Look for Specialization, Not Generalists

A therapist who works with "a wide range of concerns" isn't necessarily a red flag, but someone who specializes in what you're bringing tends to be more effective.

If you're dealing with trauma, look for someone trained in trauma-focused approaches like EMDR, CPT, or somatic therapy. If you're navigating anxiety, ask whether they work with the specific kind — social anxiety, health anxiety, generalized anxiety, and panic disorder each respond to somewhat different approaches. If you're a first responder, veteran, or work in a high-stress field, a therapist with experience in occupational trauma will understand your world in ways a generalist might not.

Specialization means they've seen your situation before. That matters.

The Therapeutic Relationship Is the Most Important Variable

Research consistently shows that the quality of the relationship between therapist and client is one of the strongest predictors of outcomes — more than any specific technique or modality.

What does a good therapeutic relationship feel like? You should feel:

  • Heard without judgment — like you can say the hard thing and not be met with shock or advice
  • Challenged without pressure — a good therapist will gently push you, but never in a way that feels unsafe
  • Respected — your pace, your values, your history
  • Like yourself — not performing or managing how you come across

You don't have to feel completely comfortable right away. Some discomfort is part of the work. But if after a few sessions you consistently feel worse, dismissed, or like you're not being understood, it's okay to keep looking.

Questions Worth Asking in a Consultation

Most therapists offer a free 15–20 minute consultation. Use it. Some questions that actually tell you something:

  • "What does a typical session look like with you?" — This tells you whether they're structured or more open-ended, directive or collaborative.
  • "Have you worked with people dealing with [your specific concern]?" — You want a yes with some specifics, not a vague "of course."
  • "What approaches or modalities do you use?" — If they can't explain their approach in plain language, that's worth noting.
  • "How do you handle it if a client feels like things aren't working?" — A good therapist welcomes this question.

You're not being difficult by asking. You're being a good advocate for yourself.

Telehealth Is a Real Option

If you've been putting off therapy because of scheduling, commute, or the idea of sitting in a waiting room — telehealth removes most of those barriers.

Video sessions are just as effective as in-person for most concerns, including anxiety, trauma, life transitions, and burnout. You can do a session from your car, your lunch break, or your living room. For people with demanding jobs, young kids, or limited local options, telehealth has genuinely changed what's accessible.

If you're in Florida or North Carolina, I offer telehealth sessions and am happy to answer any questions about whether it might be a good fit for what you're navigating.

It's Okay If the First Person Isn't the Right One

Therapy is a relationship, and not every relationship is the right one. If you try someone and it doesn't feel right after a few sessions, that's not a failure — it's information. Keep going.

The right fit is worth finding. And once you find it, the work tends to move.

Explore Topics

#therapy#finding a therapist#mental health#telehealth#counseling
K

Written by

Kimberleigh Stickney, LMHC

Content creator and writer sharing insights and stories.